▶ Video explainer coming soon
The Appellate Division reversed the lower court. It found the contract's definition of 'Refunds' was clear and included 'reductions in bills' or 'benefits' from any transaction related to the lease. Since the purchase option was mentioned in the original lease, the court said the purchase counted as a related transaction. The court also noted the contract said commissions wouldn't be reduced no matter what other deals the client made. Because the agreement gave the auditing company exclusive rights, it didn't matter whether the company found or caused these savings itself. The court granted summary judgment to the auditing company on liability and sent the case back to calculate the amount owed.
Commercial Tenant Services was hired in 2013 to audit whether its client was being overcharged by its landlord. Their contract said the company would earn a commission on any 'Refunds' the client received. While the audit was happening, the client used an option in its lease to buy its office building when it became a condominium. As part of that deal, the landlord lowered management fees and changed how expenses were calculated, saving the client money. After the purchase closed, the client ended its relationship with the auditing company. The auditing company then sued, claiming those savings counted as 'Refunds' under their agreement, entitling it to a commission.
The main question was whether savings from buying the building counted as a 'Refund' under the contract. The client argued only rent-related savings counted. The lower court agreed and dismissed the case. The auditing company appealed, arguing the contract's definition of 'Refunds' was broader and covered these savings too.
This ruling shows how courts read contract language exactly as written, especially when terms are clearly defined. Broad or 'exclusive' service agreements can obligate a party to pay commissions even on benefits they didn't directly help create. It's a reminder that specific wording in business contracts can carry major financial consequences.
Talk to a licensed landlord tenant lawyer in New York.